Being arrested for DUI in Orlando can create far-reaching effects that profoundly alter your future. A single mistake or misunderstanding can lead to license suspension, jail time, and lasting damage to your career and public standing.This process moves quickly, and the decisions you make in the first days after arrest will shape your case’s trajectory. At Rentz Law, we understand what you’re facing, and we know how to help.
How Rentz Law Can Help After a DUI Arrest in Orlando
Local expertise – Carrie has defended DUI cases in both the Orange County Courthouse (425 N. Orange Avenue) and the Seminole County Criminal Justice Center (Sanford). She knows the local procedures and has experience with the judges and prosecutors.
Hands-on representation – Your case is handled personally by Carrie, no hand-offs to junior attorneys or case managers.
Communication your way – You’ll always have direct access to your lawyer by text, phone, or email.
Meet Your DUI Defense Attorney
With two decades of criminal defense experience, Carrie L. Rentz has successfully represented clients charged with DUI, drug possession, and other serious offenses throughout Central Florida. She has in-depth knowledge of Orlando’s DUI enforcement patterns, the Florida Highway Patrol’s Troop D procedures, and how to challenge roadside testing, breath results, and officer reports.
Carrie approaches each case with empathy and precision—focusing on evidence, procedure, and how the arrest was handled from the very start.
20+ Years of Experience Serving Orange and Seminole Counties
How We Defend DUI Cases
Every DUI case has its own set of unique circumstances, so our approach is always strategic, evidence-driven, and personal.
- Initial Consultation – We start by reviewing the circumstances of your arrest, the officer’s report, and the evidence against you. This includes examining the traffic stop, field sobriety test procedures, and any breath or blood test results. From there, we determine your best path forward.
- Investigation & Strategy – We dig deep into the details of your case. This may include reviewing body cam footage, interviewing witnesses, analyzing maintenance logs for breathalyzer devices, and consulting experts on medical conditions that could mimic impairment. If your rights were violated or the stop lacked probable cause, we move to have evidence suppressed.
- Court Representation – Whether your case is resolved through negotiation or trial, we handle it aggressively and thoughtfully. We file motions to dismiss when warranted, negotiate for reduced charges such as reckless driving, and prepare a full defense if your case proceeds to trial.
- Possible Outcomes – Depending on your situation, outcomes can include case dismissal, participation in DUI diversion programs, reduction to a lesser offense, or sentencing alternatives that protect your license and record.
- Communication & Support – You’ll never be left wondering what’s next. Carrie keeps you informed and provides direct access by phone, text, or email so you’re part of the process at every stage.
Your Right to Fair Representation
Being charged with a DUI does not mean you’re guilty. You have the constitutional right to remain silent, the right to an attorney, and the right to a fair trial. Unfortunately, many DUI arrests in Florida involve questionable stops, unreliable testing, or rushed investigations that violate those rights.
At Rentz Law, we hold law enforcement and prosecutors accountable. We ensure that evidence collected against you was obtained legally and that you are treated fairly throughout the process. Our role is not only to defend your case but to defend your dignity—protecting your future, your freedom, and your reputation.
Understanding DUI Charges and Penalties in Florida
Under Florida Statute §316.193, a driver can be charged with Driving Under the Influence (DUI) if they:
- Have a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.08% or higher, or
- Are under the influence of alcohol, controlled substances, or prescription medication to the extent that normal faculties are impaired.
In Orlando, DUI arrests frequently occur near downtown nightlife areas like Orange Avenue, Wall Street Plaza, and Church Street, as well as along I-4, Colonial Drive (SR 50), SR 436 near Altamonte Springs, and International Drive. The Orlando Police Department and Florida Highway Patrol regularly conduct sobriety checkpoints in these zones, particularly on weekends and holidays.
First DUI Offense Penalties in Florida
A first DUI is typically a misdemeanor but carries serious consequences, including:
- Up to 6 months in jail (9 months if BAC ≥ 0.15).
- Fines between $500–$1,000.
- Up to 1-year license suspension.
- 50 hours of community service.
- Mandatory DUI school and probation.
Many first-time offenders in Orange County may be eligible for diversion or a “wet reckless” reduction under Florida law, avoiding a permanent DUI conviction. Rentz Law focuses on helping clients pursue these alternative outcomes whenever possible.
Second DUI Offense Penalties
A second DUI within five years carries enhanced penalties:
- Minimum 10 days in jail.
- Fines up to $2,000.
- 5-year license suspension.
- Ignition interlock device required.
- Vehicle impoundment and higher insurance rates.
For second offenses, Carrie Rentz examines whether the first conviction was handled properly and whether enhanced sentencing truly applies (errors in prior cases can sometimes reduce penalties or disqualify enhancements).
Felony DUI and Aggravated Circumstances
Some DUI cases become felonies, especially if:
- It’s the third DUI within 10 years,
- Someone was injured or killed, or
- The driver had a minor in the vehicle or a BAC ≥ 0.15.
A felony DUI carries up to 5 years in prison, heavy fines, and potential lifetime license revocation. In cases involving injury or death, the prosecution must prove causation: that intoxication, not another factor, caused the crash. Rentz Law works with accident reconstruction experts to challenge these claims and ensure no assumptions are accepted as fact.
Common DUI Defenses
Many DUI defenses share a common goal: exposing mistakes in the arrest process or during evidence collection.
Here are a few ways DUI charges can be challenged:
- Unlawful Stop: Officers must have reasonable suspicion or probable cause to stop your vehicle. Random or pretextual stops can result in evidence being thrown out.
- Faulty Breath or Blood Tests: Machines must be properly calibrated and maintained. We often find gaps in maintenance logs or operator certification.
- Improper Field Sobriety Tests: These tests are subjective and can be affected by fatigue, nerves, or medical conditions.
- No Proof of Actual Impairment: The presence of alcohol or medication does not always mean impairment. We challenge how impairment was measured and documented.
- Violation of Miranda Rights or Improper Procedure: If your rights were not read or your arrest was mishandled, your case may be dismissed.
How Common are DUI Arrests in Orange County?
Recent state data shows just how frequently DUI charges occur across Central Florida and how many cases can be challenged successfully.
According to the 2024 Florida Uniform Traffic Citation Statistics, there were 1,457 DUI violations reported in Orange County, and 634 of those drivers were found guilty. Another 24% of cases were dropped or not prosecuted, highlighting how often arrests don’t lead to convictions.
In Seminole County, local law enforcement issued 591 DUI citations throughout 2024, with 38 cases dismissed, not prosecuted, or found not guilty.
Most of these arrests originate from patrols and checkpoints along I-4, Semoran Boulevard (SR 436), Colonial Drive (SR 50), and downtown Orlando nightlife zones such as Orange Avenue and Church Street.
These numbers prove that while DUI enforcement is aggressive in Central Florida, the evidence doesn’t always hold up in court. Breath test errors, improper stops, and procedural mistakes can make the difference between a conviction and a dismissal—that’s where a strong defense matters most.
What to Do (and Avoid) After a DUI Arrest
The steps you take after an arrest can directly affect the outcome of your case.
- Do not talk to police without an attorney. Anything you say can be used against you.
- Do not post about your case online. Even minor comments can be misinterpreted.
- Keep all paperwork. Save citations, court notices, and your DMV hearing information.
- Act quickly. You have 10 days from your arrest to request a DMV hearing to fight your license suspension.
- Contact Rentz Law immediately. Early legal representation gives you the best chance to preserve your license and challenge your charges effectively.
Navigating the Legal System in Central Florida
DUI cases in Orlando are handled through the Orange County Court’s Traffic and Criminal Division, located downtown at 425 N. Orange Avenue. Seminole County DUI cases go through the Criminal Justice Center in Sanford.
Carrie Rentz appears regularly in both courts and understands how each jurisdiction handles DUI cases. Some judges emphasize alcohol education and treatment programs for first-time offenders, while others prefer strict sentencing. This local insight allows Rentz Law to craft defense strategies that fit both your case and the court’s expectations.
What Our Clients Are Saying
Carrie was extremely helpful in a difficult situation. She was detailed, easy to communicate with and provided a favorable result in the end. If your looking for a great attorney pick up the phone and call Carrie today!
Carrie is everything as advertised. She actually puts in time and effort to get to know you and shows true sympathy toward her clients. Great people skills and even better knowledge of the law. Highly recommended!
When I initially called Carrie I was hesitant, scared, and didn't know what to expect. I can tell you first hand, Carrie and her assistant are AMAZING. I would recommend to anyone and everyone. Good luck Carrie on your future endeavors, all the best.
I hired Mrs. Rentz for a legal issue I had in the Orlando area. Being from out of town, I use some references as a guide. Mrs. Rentz looked to be the right attorney. She is very caring and takes your issue very seriously.
This was by far the best experience i have had with a lawyer she always let me know what was going on with my case and always stayed positive while fighting for me in the courtroom. Just want to say i appreciate everything you have done for me and will definitely recommend you to anyone. If i could it would be 10 stars, thank you again
Carrie was wonderful to work with. She made the entire process so smooth for me and was always easy to get in touch with whenever I had any questions.
Carrie Rentz is an amazing lawyer. She is very informed and ready to answer any questions I have. She and her assistant reply to emails in a timely fashion and are both very friendly and knowledgeable. If you are looking for a lawyer I 100% recommend her.
DUI FAQs
Can I refuse a breathalyzer test in Florida?
Yes, but refusal leads to an automatic license suspension under Florida’s implied consent law.
Can a DUI be reduced to reckless driving?
Yes. Depending on evidence and prior record, prosecutors may agree to reduce a DUI to reckless driving, especially for first-time offenders.
Do I need a lawyer for a first DUI?
Absolutely. Even a first conviction can affect your license, job, and insurance rates. A defense attorney can often reduce or dismiss the charge.
How long does a DUI stay on my record?
A DUI remains on your driving record for 75 years in Florida, which is effectively permanent.
Where do most DUI arrests happen in Orlando?
Common areas include Orange Avenue, Wall Street Plaza, I-4 near downtown, Colonial Drive (SR 50), International Drive, and the UCF corridor near Alafaya Trail.
