If you’ve been charged with theft in Orlando, Orange County, or Seminole County, there’s no doubt about your future being on the line. A conviction can harm your career and impact your housing options and reputation for years to come. At Rentz Law, we understand what’s at stake. Attorney Carrie L. Rentz has more than 20 years of experience fighting for clients facing criminal charges in Central Florida. She brings aggressive advocacy, personal attention, and a compassionate approach to every case. Your defense deserves nothing less.
How Rentz Law Can Help After a Theft Arrest in Orlando
Local expertise – We have decades of experience in the Orange County Courthouse and Seminole County Criminal Justice Center.
Personal attention – As a boutique, woman-led firm, we provide the compassion and individualized strategy your case deserves.
Communication your way – We stay accessible by text, phone, or email, so you’re never left in the dark.
Meet Your Theft Defense Attorney
Carrie L. Rentz is a seasoned criminal defense attorney with a strong record of success in theft and property crime cases. She is admitted to practice throughout Florida; recognized by peers for her professionalism; and trusted by clients for her straightforward, compassionate guidance. Carrie personally handles every case, ensuring you always know who is standing beside you in court.
20+ Years of Experience Serving Orange and Seminole Counties
How We Defend Theft Cases
Every theft case is different, but our approach is always hands-on and assertive.
- Initial Consultation – We review your arrest, charges, and the evidence to determine your options.
- Investigation & Strategy – From questioning surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts to negotiating restitution, we pursue every angle.
- Court Representation – We file motions, negotiate with prosecutors, and prepare for trial when necessary.
- Possible Outcomes – Dismissal, diversion programs, reduced charges, acquittal, or sentencing mitigation.
- Communication & Support – You’ll always know where your case stands, with direct access to your attorney by phone, text, or email.
Your Right to Fair Representation
Being accused of theft does not make you guilty. You have the right to be presumed innocent, to confront your accuser, and to defend yourself in court. Rentz Law guarantees that your rights are fully protected at every stage of your case. These are exactly the types of charges we defend daily, and our experience with local courts helps us protect your freedom and your future.
How Common Are Theft Arrests in Orange County?
Under Florida law, theft occurs when someone knowingly takes or uses another person’s property with the intent to deprive them of it. Depending on the value of the property and prior history, theft charges can range from misdemeanors to serious felonies.
In Orange and Seminole Counties, theft-related arrests are among the most common. According to data from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE), shoplifting and petit theft account for a significant percentage of misdemeanor cases, while grand theft arrests involving vehicles, credit cards, or property over $750 lead to felony charges.
- 2020: 5,914 crimes against property arrests in Orange County
- 2020: 1,380 crimes against property arrests in Seminole County
Not every arrest means someone actually committed theft. Misunderstandings, mistaken identity, or even false accusations are common in property crime cases. A person might have had permission to use an item, been in the wrong place at the wrong time, or simply lacked the intent to permanently take someone else’s property — which is a key part of Florida’s theft laws. At Rentz Law, we work to uncover these details, challenge weak evidence, and make sure our clients are not unfairly punished for crimes they did not commit.
Theft Charges and Consequences in Florida
Types of theft charges in Florida include:
- Petit Theft (Second-Degree Misdemeanor): Property valued under $100
- Petit Theft (First-Degree Misdemeanor): Property valued between $100 and $750
- Grand Theft (Felony): Property valued at $750 or more, with penalties increasing at higher thresholds
Consequences of a theft conviction can include: Jail time, probation, heavy fines, restitution, driver’s license suspension for repeat offenders, and a permanent criminal record that cannot be sealed or expunged if convicted.
What to Do (and Avoid) After a Theft Arrest
The steps you take after an arrest can directly affect the outcome of your case.
- Do not speak to police without an attorney. Anything you say may be used against you.
- Avoid posting about your case on social media. Even innocent comments can be misinterpreted.
- Keep all paperwork. Save bond documents, court dates, and receipts.
- Contact a criminal defense attorney immediately. Acting quickly gives you the best chance of a favorable outcome.
Navigating the Legal System in Central Florida
Every county has unique procedures, judges, and prosecutors. Rentz Law has defended clients in both the Orange County Courthouse (downtown Orlando) and the Seminole County Criminal Justice Center (Sanford). Our familiarity with local prosecutors and courtrooms allows us to anticipate strategies; negotiate effectively; and fight for dismissals, reduced charges, or diversion programs that protect your record.
What Our Clients Are Saying
Carrie was extremely helpful in a difficult situation. She was detailed, easy to communicate with and provided a favorable result in the end. If your looking for a great attorney pick up the phone and call Carrie today!
Carrie is everything as advertised. She actually puts in time and effort to get to know you and shows true sympathy toward her clients. Great people skills and even better knowledge of the law. Highly recommended!
When I initially called Carrie I was hesitant, scared, and didn't know what to expect. I can tell you first hand, Carrie and her assistant are AMAZING. I would recommend to anyone and everyone. Good luck Carrie on your future endeavors, all the best.
I hired Mrs. Rentz for a legal issue I had in the Orlando area. Being from out of town, I use some references as a guide. Mrs. Rentz looked to be the right attorney. She is very caring and takes your issue very seriously.
This was by far the best experience i have had with a lawyer she always let me know what was going on with my case and always stayed positive while fighting for me in the courtroom. Just want to say i appreciate everything you have done for me and will definitely recommend you to anyone. If i could it would be 10 stars, thank you again
Carrie was wonderful to work with. She made the entire process so smooth for me and was always easy to get in touch with whenever I had any questions.
Carrie Rentz is an amazing lawyer. She is very informed and ready to answer any questions I have. She and her assistant reply to emails in a timely fashion and are both very friendly and knowledgeable. If you are looking for a lawyer I 100% recommend her.
Theft Crimes FAQs
What is the difference between petit theft and grand theft in Florida?
Petit theft involves property valued under $750, while grand theft covers anything above that threshold. Grand theft is a felony and carries more severe penalties.
Can a theft charge be dropped in Orlando?
Yes. Charges may be dropped if evidence is weak, if restitution is made, or through pretrial diversion programs. Each case depends on its individual circumstances.
Will a theft conviction stay on my record forever?
In Florida, theft convictions cannot be sealed or expunged. That’s why it is critical to fight for dismissal, diversion, or reduction before conviction.
Can I get a shoplifting charge expunged?
If your case is dismissed, dropped, or resolved without a conviction, you may be eligible to seal or expunge your record.
What are the penalties for shoplifting in Orange or Seminole County?
Penalties range from fines and probation to jail time, depending on the value of the property and prior offenses.
